U3A Benalla
  • Home
  • Benalla
    • Benalla
    • Benalla District
    • Who, What and Where? - Benalla Rural City
  • About
    • Our U3A
    • President's Page
    • Executive Committee
    • Policies
    • Convenors >
      • Convenors
      • Convenors A - Z July 2025
    • Program Ideas
    • Newsletter
    • Website
  • Groups
    • Groups - 2025
    • Groups - 2026
    • Past Groups >
      • A Different View Of German History
      • Apple Refresher Course
      • Armchair History - an Australian History
      • Armchair History (British)
      • Armchair Traveller
      • Booker Reading Group
      • Bushwalking - Mid-week Walks
      • Chess
      • Colour Mixing and Watercolour Techniques - Botanical
      • Comparative Religion
      • Cooking Solo
      • Demystifying Psychology - Introductory Course
      • Demystifying Psychology - Perception
      • Enjoying the Internet
      • Exploring Writing Children's Books
      • Facebook for Mentors
      • Family Research - Advanced
      • Family Research Drop In
      • French at the Table
      • German - Beginners
      • History - An Introduction to Western Civilization
      • History - Moments in Australian History
      • Hot Topics/The News - Fact or Fiction?
      • 'In the Lap of the Gods'
      • Investment I (1996 -2015)
      • Jane Austen Book Club
      • Legal Matters (Short Course)
      • Lifeball >
        • Home
        • Lifeball Videos
      • Meditation
      • Making the Most of the Internet
      • On Target - Learning to Shop Online
      • Opera
      • 'Over There'
      • Rail and Tourism
      • Russian Literature
      • Sky's the Limit
      • Spanish
      • Tech Savvy Apple Devices - Intermediate
      • Tech Savvy Community Projects
      • Tech Savvy Plus & Google Apps
      • Travel Group
      • Wise Guys Book Group
      • Zoom Short Course
  • A - B
    • A-Ch
    • 'A Taste of Art'
    • American History
    • Art Appreciation
    • 'As Time Goes By'
    • Australian Shares and Stock Market
    • Be Connected - Android
    • Be Connected - Tech Advice
    • Birdwatching
    • Brain Games - Neurobics
  • C - E
    • Ch - E
    • Car Torque
    • Cards '500'
    • Chat n' Chew
    • Coin Collectors
    • Collectors
    • Community Singing
    • Creative Writing
    • Demystifying Psychology - Discussion Group
    • Easy Bushwalking
    • Exercises for Fun
    • Exploring the Universe
  • F-Pa
    • F- Pa
    • Family Research
    • Film Discussion
    • Garden Appreciation
    • Garden Team
    • German >
      • German Home
      • Lessons
    • Let's Talk Books
    • Mahjong
    • Meet and Mingle
    • Music Appreciation
    • Page Turners
    • Patchwork and Craft
  • Ph-W
    • Ph -W
    • Photography
    • Pickleball
    • Play Reading
    • Politics & Current Affairs
    • Recorder
    • Singing for Fun
    • Sustainability & Stock and Land
    • Tech Talks
    • Train Buffs
    • Ukes4Fun
    • Wine Appreciation
  • Join
    • Join Us
    • Membership Application/Renewal Form
    • Program Guide - Sem 2
    • Timetable with Dates Sem 2
    • Venues and Maps
  • News
    • December Newsletter
    • News Blog
    • 'What's On' Calendar 2025
    • Monthly Calendar
    • Website & Facebook
  • FB
  • Gallery
  • Links
    • Resources and References
    • U3A Network Victoria
    • Seniors Online Victoria
    • U3A Albury Wodonga
    • U3A Beechworth (Indigo U3A)
    • U3A Bright
    • U3A Goulburn Valley
    • U3A Murrundindee East
    • U3A Wangaratta
  • Contact

'Friends'

28/3/2023

0 Comments

 
Bet and Jess were actually friends of my mother. We lived in Hobart – three little girls and a mountain of steps to the front door.

Jess, who came from Queensland, was visiting her sister when my father met her. Within days she was living with us and helping my mother with the family. Jess studied at night, got a job, but still lived with us until we moved to Launceston. We loved her.

Betty came from Penguin and was a trainee teacher in Grade 1 at Elizabeth Street State School. I was very unsure of myself, so much so that I regularly bit the corners off my collars! The teacher didn’t have time to show me any special attention, but Betty encouraged me and gave me confidence. Meanwhile the Penguin Methodist minister got in touch with my Dad to ask him to look out for Betty. She became best friends with Jess and was at our place more often than not.
​
‘Auntie Elsie’ lived with us in Launceston. Her real name was Elsie Kemp whose father made Kempo soap. I’m not sure why she lived with us except that she was a member of Moral Rearmament as was my mother. One memory of  Elsie was after the family had arrived home from church one Sunday. She said to Mother, “Beth, the Lord has told me I’m to have pineapple for lunch.” My mother’s reply, “Well Else, the Lord has told me that you are to have custard and stewed apple like everyone else”. When a new baby was due, Auntie Elsie said, “I’ll look after Dorothy and Thais but I won’t have Carmyl!” I might say the feeling was quite mutual.

So dear Bet took me up to Penguin for a fortnight with her family, which consisted of her mother, her white-bearded grandfather and Murray, her 16 year-old brother. Murray only had one arm as he’d been run over by a train when young.  I was about six and my only memory was of Murray showing me a mouse trap and telling me to put my finger in it – and of course I did. Murray later became a Baptist minister and his claim to fame was that when the bridge broke in Hobart, his was the car dangling over the edge.

We moved to a small town near Beaconsfield while Dad was in the army. Bet came to visit and needed to see a doctor. Dr. Suerth was an Austrian Jew, who had escaped to Italy, converted to Catholicism and ended up in Beaconsfield. The long and the short of it was that Betty ended up as Mrs. Suerth. They married at the Ulverstone Catholic church, with broad steps up to the front door. Some Penguin Methodists stood on the steps as Bet entered the church calling out, “It’s not too late to change your mind Betty!”

The Suerths later moved to Hobart and Jess and Bet were reunited. Both visited us on occasions. Jess came to our wedding and wrote it up for the Geelong Advertiser. She had the knack of describing the fabrics of the dresses in terms only used by a modelling agency!

We visited them both in Hobart a couple of times. These wonderful women died only recently, both well into their 90s. They were pretty special people.
Picture
Jess, Carmyl, Betty

​Carmyl Winkler
March 29, 2023
0 Comments

'Failure'

5/3/2023

0 Comments

 
I mentioned this title to my son, who wisely commented, “Well it all depends where you set the bar.’

By most people’s bar, my athletic career would be a complete failure – in the seconds for the school hockey team, playing in D Grade in the church tennis team, last by a third of the pool in the year 9 swimming sports.

But I once won a race at the Sunday School picnic. I was about 18 and we were running on the sand at Torquay and somehow I managed to beat Joycie Ford, well-known as the best runner in the race. My athletic husband-to-be couldn’t have been prouder!

But if the bar was low in that field of endeavour, it was right up there in the academic arena – second wasn’t good enough. I did once get PL, pass at a lower standard, in Year 9 Art but any other subject was grist to the mill.

I was fortunate enough to live in the era of Commonwealth Scholarships. They weren’t too hard to get and the associated living allowance was dependant on your family income so I did well in this regard.

However university was in Melbourne and we lived in Geelong so money had to be stretched to cover living expenses. I enrolled at University Women’s College and sat for a College Scholarship and was successful. With both scholarships I had just enough to live on. Students working at paid jobs during the term was not even considered in that era as learning was a full time task, especially for science students who had 3 hours of practical work each week for each subject as well as lectures.

First year science – and a pretty raw recruit. Notes were taken during lectures and, in Physics, a weekly problem sheet was handed out. The first one was headed with a Bible quotation:

‘But be ye doers of the word and not hearers only, deceiving your own selves’

I diligently did the problems but didn’t think to further check over or rewrite each lecture.

A Science degree required two terms learning Science French or Science German. I decided to do this in my first year and, while no oral work was required but simply the ability to translate  scientific articles from these languages into English, my love of languages inveigled me into spending too much  time on this subject.

By exam time I had a large amount of material to revise and ,yes, my results were an utter disappointment – one third class honour and three passes. I lost my college scholarship and felt utterly miserable.

I spent the three month Christmas holidays as a pseudo-nurse at the Geelong Hospital. I saved every penny and made it financially to the end of my second year when my results were good enough to have my scholarship restored. By the end of my third year I was offered a position as Physics tutor at the college.
​
Sometimes we have to fail first time round to learn about what life asks of us.
Carmyl Winkler
March 2023
0 Comments
    Our Stories

    Carmyl's stories

    Carmyl joined 'As Time Goes by' in 2022.  Carmyl's first story,  'I Was There', took us to Indonesia in the early 1960's.

    Picture

    Stories

    All
    'Aceh 1961'
    '(....) Adventure'
    'Advice'
    'A Long Lost Friend'
    'A Sense Of Place'
    'A Steep Learning Curve'
    'A Year That Changed Me'
    'Bronwyn'
    'Bucket List'
    'Causes' - The Multi-Cultural Program
    'Communicating'
    'Community'
    'Education Of A Princess'
    'Emergence'
    'Failure'
    'First Of April'
    'Footprints'
    'Friends'
    'Her Story'
    'How Can I Keep From Singing?'
    'I Changed My Mind'
    'Indonesia'
    'I Was There'
    Memoir Review
    'Memories Treasure Chest'
    'My Brilliant Career As Mrs Hinchcliffe'
    'My First ...(Boyfriend)'
    'My Happy Place'
    'My Special Project'
    'One Moment
    One-moment-this-year
    'Reflecting On COVID'
    'Retirement'
    'Right Here
    Right Now'
    'Sandy Beach 1945'
    'Scars'
    'Shaped By Childhood'
    'She'll Make A List'
    'Sixty-three Years Ago'
    'Someone Who Shaped Me'
    'The Trigger'
    'The Winter Cut Came To Visit'
    'This (Reading) Life'
    This Year'
    This Year' (2023)
    'Time Travelling'
    'Trees'

    Archives

    November 2025
    October 2025
    September 2025
    August 2025
    July 2025
    June 2025
    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    January 2025
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    November 2022
    October 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022

    RSS Feed

We acknowledge the traditional owners of the land on which we meet and pay our respects to their elders - past, present and emerging.
Picture
News
​Newsletter
Facebook Page
​
Program Suggestions
​CO-VID Safety

U3A Benalla Flier 2025
Membership Application/Renewal
​
Semester 2 Program Guide 2025
Semester 2 Timetable with Dates 2025
Developed and maintained by members, this website showcases U3A Benalla 
​Photographs - U3A members; Benalla Art Gallery website; ​Weebly 'Free' images;Travel Victoria and State Library of Victoria