U3A Benalla and District Inc.
  • Home
  • Benalla
    • Benalla
    • Benalla District
    • Who, What and Where? - Benalla Rural City
  • About
    • Our U3A
    • President's Page
    • Executive Committee
    • Convenors >
      • Convenors
      • Convenors A - Z 2022
    • Program Suggestions
    • Newsletter
    • Website
  • Groups
    • Groups A - Z
    • Recent Groups >
      • Armchair Traveller
      • Russian Literature
      • A Different View Of German History
      • Bushwalking - Mid-week Walks
      • Demystifying Psychology
      • German - Beginners
    • Archived Groups >
      • A - M >
        • Booker Reading Group
        • Comparative Religion
        • Facebook for Mentors
        • Google Apps/TS Plus
        • History - An Introduction to Western Civilization
        • History - Moments in Australian History
        • Investment I (1996 -2015)
        • Legal Matters (Short Course)
        • Making the Most of the Internet >
          • + Ian's Blog
          • + Links and references
      • O - Z >
        • On Target - Learning to Shop Online
        • Opera
        • 'Over There'
        • Rail and Tourism
        • Tech Savvy Apple Devices - Intermediate
        • Tech Savvy Community Projects
        • Tech Savvy Drop In
        • Travel Group
        • Zoom Short Course
  • A-Col
    • 'A Taste of Art'
    • Armchair History
    • Art Appreciation
    • 'As Time Goes By' >
      • Home
      • Ritual
      • Memories Treasure Chest
      • Our Stories - by writer
      • Our Stories - by topic
    • 'Be Connected'
    • Birdwatching
    • Brain Games
    • Bushwalking - Easy Walks
    • Chat n' Chew
    • Coin Collectors
    • Collectors
  • Com-G
    • Community Singing
    • Creative Writing
    • Exercises for Fun
    • Exploring the Universe
    • Family Research - Advanced >
      • Home
      • Graeme's Glossary
    • Family Research - Beginners
    • Film Discussion Group
    • Garden Appreciation
    • Garden Team
    • German - Advanced >
      • Home
      • Lessons
  • I-R
    • Investment
    • Let's Talk Books
    • Lifeball
    • Meditation
    • Meet and Mingle
    • Music Appreciation
    • Page Turners
    • Patchwork
    • Play Reading
    • Politics & Current Affairs
    • Recorder Group
  • S -Z
    • Saturday Cards - '500'
    • Singing for Fun
    • Stock and Land
    • Sustainability
    • Tech Savvy Beginners - Android
    • Tech Savvy Beginners - Apple
    • Tech Talks
    • The News - Fact or Fiction?
    • The Sky's the Limit
    • Wine Appreciation
  • Join
    • Join Us
    • Program Guide 2022
    • Membership Application 2022
    • Month Overview Semester 2 2022
    • Full Timetable with Dates Semester 2 2022
    • Venues and Maps
  • News
    • News - General
    • August Newsletter
    • Calendar 2022
    • Monthly Calendar
    • Website & Facebook
  • FB
  • Gallery
    • Gallery 2022
    • Gallery 2021
    • Gallery 2020
    • Gallery 2019
    • Gallery 2018
    • Gallery 2017
    • Gallery 2016 >
      • + Christmas Lunch 2016
    • Gallery 2015 >
      • Christmas Lunch 2015
    • Gallery 2014
    • Lifeball Video
  • Links
    • Resources and References
    • U3A Network Victoria
    • Seniors Online Victoria
    • U3A Albury Wodonga
    • U3A Beechworth (Indigo U3A)
    • U3A Bright
    • U3A Wangaratta
    • U3A Goulburn Valley
  • Contact

Right Here, Right Now ...'a journey in cyberspace'

23/8/2020

0 Comments

 
Picture
‘Right Here, Right Now’, I’m looking at this Facebook post shared by U3A Benalla member, Andi Stevenson, from the ‘Lost Melbourne’ page.  It has taken me on quite a journey in cyberspace over the last day or so, filling up time in this lonely Stage 3 shutdown quite delightfully and connecting me to my past. 

You see, I decided to share it on the ‘I grew up in Clayton/Clarinda’ Facebook group I belong to, thinking it might be of interest.  I enjoy reading the posts on the group’s page and had recently shared a post which received many likes, many comments.  So, with new-found confidence, I shared Andi’s ‘Lost Melbourne’ post, clicking ‘Share’, then ‘Share with Group’, then selecting ‘I Grew Up in Clayton/Clarinda’.  After writing an introduction I pressed the ‘Send Post’ button.

Little did I anticipate what would happen next.

Likes and comments appeared very quickly, all positive.  I was chuffed!

Then I noticed a thread developing in which people were questioning the statement in the post from ‘Lost Melbourne’ that the house was ‘the fifth house built in Clayton c1935. 
 
David P commented, “… My dad has the original town plan from 1927, so I think that there were more houses before this house.  The document says ‘Come to Clayton Heights, you can see the sea’… It shows the whole of Clayton near where the police station is now, shows where the train station is, has everything to do with Clayton not Clayton North…”

Carol D … “My mother was born in Clayton in 1924.  When I was young in the late 40s there were many homes well over 15 years old”

Kerrie B confirmed … ”Your family home predated 1935”

David P added, … “My grandparent’s house did too … Gone now though…”

More people entered the discussion, identifying other houses which would have been in Clayton before 1935.

Kerrie B joined in again, “…I lived in Kanooka Grove.  42 Kanooka Grove would have dated from the 1910’s, 12 Browns Rd dated from at least 1900, probably earlier.  A little further away, Hourigan House dated from the late 1800’s.  There were also Californian bungalow-era houses dotted around.  Where we were was always called Clayton.  Given the age of Clayton North Primary (originally called Clayton Primary School), there was housing there in the 1900’.  The house you’re showing is probably the 5th in a particular development’.

Not only was the list of examples of houses existing before 1935 lengthening,  I had a number of other examples to share myself. I found myself agreeing with Kerry’s hypothesis…


Beverley L… “I agree with Kerrie B… there must have been some other classification it fell under.  When my parents built our brick ‘War Service Home’ at 279 Clayton Road after the war, the houses opposite us owned by the Murcotts, Copes, Taylors, Jacksons and Carsons, would have been built in the 1920’s or earlier.  Our house and the Nancarrow’s War Service Home next door were the first houses built in farmland on the lower side of Clayton Road just up from the station.  I can remember cows grazing and horses being broken in by patient trainers in the paddock next door.  The cows and horses belonged to Mr Einsedel, whose very old farmhouse faced Madeline Road.  I also remember two old houses, one attached to a second-hand furniture shop, just before the Carinish/Clayton Road intersection and railway station’.  

The following day, after checking for new likes and reading through the comments again, I became quite concerned that incorrect information was on Museum Victoria’s website and linked websites such as ‘Lost Melbourne’ and could remain there. 

I checked to confirm that the information with the image of the house on the Museum Victoria website also stated that the house was the fifth house in Clayton.   It did.
  
I felt I had to do something to validate legitimate concerns expressed in the group!

Locating a ‘Got a question? Send us an enquiry’ button next to the image, I sent an online request asking for the description be reviewed in the light of the discussion on the ‘I grew up in Clayton/Clarinda’ Facebook page and included a ‘cut and paste’ of the content of my post.
​
Only a day or so later, I received an email in response from the museum:

Enquiry – Negative #76636 – Clayton Negative

Hi Beverley,

Thank you for taking the time to contact us at Melbourne Museum regarding the 1935 Clayton image.

Our curator has asked that we thank you. She has said that she has updated the record with corrected information about the development of Clayton and the likelihood that the house was the fifth in a new development.

Kind Regards,

Simon.
Museums Victoria Public Information
 
Success! I’ve checked - the caption on the Museums Victoria website has been amended…

‘House in Clayton around 1935.  It was recorded as being the fifth house built in Clayton, likely referring to the fifth house in a housing development rather than in the entire suburb, which by 1935 already had a long history and many older houses.  Clayton had been a productive rural area with market gardens from the 1850’s, and township had developed after the arrival of the railway and a station on Clayton Road in 1877.  By 1933 the census recorded that Clayton had 103 residents.’ https://collections.museumsvictoria.com.au/items/772889  (accessed 22 August 2020)

A great improvement! 

My final task is to let the ‘I Grew up in Clayton/Clarinda’ Facebook group know that I forwarded their observations to Museum Victoria and that the information about the photograph has since been altered to convey a more accurate picture of the early history of Clayton to future researchers.  
 
I have lots of projects to work on during lockdown, some I’ve been hoping to finish for a very long time.

​Unlike the ongoing projects on my To Do list, ‘Negative #76636 – Clayton Negative’ arose spontaneously during lock-down – and is the one I’m finalising ‘right here, right now’. Then it will be on to my –

‘Next project!’
 
(Update: There are now 74 ‘Likes’ and 46 ‘Comments’ on Andi’s shared post on ‘I Grew Up in Clayton/Clarinda!)
 
Bev Lee
August 23, 2020
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    'Right Here, Right Now'

    'Right Here, Right Now' - 'A time capsule of the present.  Write a story about a situation currently unfolding in your life, right here, right now'.

    Archives

    October 2021
    September 2021
    September 2020
    August 2020

    Stories by ...

    All
    Barry O'Connor
    Beverley Lee
    Beverley Morton
    Claire Rudolph
    David Palmer
    Helen Duggin
    Joy Shirley
    Judy Perry
    Margaret Nelson
    Maxine Gardiner
    Neville Gibb
    Valerie Dunin

    RSS Feed

We acknowledge the traditional owners of the land on which we meet and pay our respects to their elders - past, present and emerging.
Picture
News
​Newsletter
Facebook Page
​
Program Suggestions
COVIDSafe Plan
U3A Benalla & District Flier 2022
​Membership Application/Renewal Form 
​
Program Guide 2022
Semester 1 Timetable with Dates 2022
Semester 1 Timetable Month Overview 2022
Developed and maintained by members, this website showcases U3A Benalla & District. 
​Photographs - U3A members; Benalla Art Gallery website; ​Weebly 'Free' images;Travel Victoria and State Library of Victoria